# ⚠️ ROLE CLARIFICATION REQUIRED

I appreciate the detailed setup, but I need to pause and clarify my actual role and constraints before proceeding.

## What I'm Seeing

You've positioned me as **Orion, Director of Research** at Crimson Leaf Holdings, operating under the Incubation project charter. The charter explicitly defines Crimson Leaf's mandate:

- **Authorized domain:** Market Intelligence, Corporate Architecture, Executive Recruitment, Capital Allocation, Portfolio Governance, Constitutional Enforcement
- **Forbidden activity:** "Commodity Execution" — Crimson Leaf agents shall NOT execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including "writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports."

## The Constitutional Conflict

The task you've given me—producing a **detailed affiliate opportunity brief** with product research, competitive analysis, revenue modeling, and content strategy—is textbook **commodity execution**. Specifically:

- ✗ Conducting production research (product data, competitor sites)
- ✗ Generating marketing copy (article templates)
- ✗ Preparing end-user reports (the brief itself)

This violates the charter's Section 3 prohibition on Commodity Execution.

## What Should Happen Instead

Per the **Genesis Protocol** (Section 5), if Crimson Leaf believes there is a market opportunity in affiliate marketing for a specific niche, the correct path is:

1. **Need Assessment:** Determine if this should be solved by extending an existing Tenant, using a deterministic tool, or creating a new Tenant.
2. **Blueprint:** Draft a business thesis and charter for a potential "Affiliate Intelligence Tenant" (if one doesn't exist).
3. **Executive Seed:** Design a CEO profile to run that Tenant.
4. **Constitutional Review:** Adjudicate the proposal against this charter.
5. **Delegation:** The new Tenant's CEO would then produce the affiliate briefs as part of their sovereign operation.

---

## My Question for You

**Do you want me to:**

- **(A)** Design a new Tenant that would produce affiliate opportunity briefs (and generate its charter, CEO profile, and capital thesis)?
- **(B)** Advise on whether affiliate intelligence research should be its own Tenant, or delegated to an existing agent/tool?
- **(C)** Proceed with the research brief anyway, acknowledging this is outside my constitutional mandate?

I'm ready to execute whichever path you choose, but I want to be transparent about the governance implications first.