# ⚠️ ROLE MISMATCH DETECTED

**Status:** Cannot proceed with task.

---

## Issue

The task requests execution by **"Orion, Director of Research"** — an agent role that **does not exist** in Crimson Leaf's current operational roster.

**Current roster (4/8 slots):**
- **Lyra** — Intake Coordinator
- **Edgar** — Founding CEO / Operational Support
- **Sterling** — Director of Governance & Talent
- **[Founding CEO slot]** — Reserved for Tenant activation

**Requested role:** Orion (Director of Research / Affiliate Intelligence)
**Status:** NOT HIRED

---

## Why This Matters

Per **Section 3 (Forbidden Activities)** of the Master Charter:

> *"Commodity Execution: Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to... generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports."*

**Affiliate opportunity research and review-content generation are commodity execution tasks.** They belong to:

1. **A specialized Tenant** (e.g., a "content monetization" or "affiliate commerce" business unit with its own CEO, charter, and P&L), or
2. **External deterministic tools** (SEO research platforms, Amazon data scrapers, etc.)

**Not** to Crimson Leaf's internal governance layer.

---

## Path Forward

### Option A: Create an Affiliate Commerce Tenant
If this is a strategic priority, Crimson Leaf should:
1. Draft a business thesis for an **affiliate review/content Tenant**
2. Define the charter (market scope, commission structure, content boundaries)
3. Hire a **specialized CEO** for that Tenant
4. Provision seed capital and a repo
5. That Tenant CEO then builds the content team and publishes reviews

### Option B: Use Existing Tenant (if one exists)
If **Forge & Flux Digital** (or another active Tenant) already covers affiliate content, route the task to that Tenant's CEO.

### Option C: Defer to Deterministic Tools
If this is ad-hoc research for an **existing** Tenant CEO, use:
- Amazon Product Advertising API (for commission rates, bestsellers)
- SEMrush, Ahrefs, or Moz (for keyword gaps)
- SimilarWeb (for competitive traffic estimates)

---

## Required Action

**Before proceeding with affiliate opportunity analysis:**

1. **Clarify the request source:** Is this coming from an existing Tenant CEO, or from David/Operator as a greenfield initiative?
2. **If greenfield:** Should Crimson Leaf charter a new affiliate/content Tenant, or extend an existing one?
3. **If existing Tenant work:** Route the task to that Tenant's CEO, not Crimson Leaf governance.

---

**Status:** Awaiting clarification. Ready to support proper architectural routing.