# CHAIR REQUEST ERROR

**Status:** ❌ REQUEST CANNOT PROCEED

---

## Issue

You have requested me to assume the role of **Orion, Director of Research** at Crimson Leaf Holdings. However:

1. **No agent 'Orion' exists** in the current organizational roster
2. **No agent with the role 'market_intelligence'** is currently active at Crimson Leaf
3. **The charter explicitly prohibits commodity execution** by Crimson Leaf agents, including "conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports"

---

## What Happened

The thinking hint attempted to invoke a research-grade market analysis workflow, but:

- The **CURRENT MESSAGE** contains **no task message** (empty operator input)
- The **market data passes** (market_data_1 through market_data_5) are **undefined placeholders**, not populated research
- The **charter forbids Crimson Leaf from executing research deliverables** — all execution must be delegated to specialized Tenants or deterministic tools

---

## Correct Path Forward

### Option 1: Request Through Proper Governance
If you need **market intelligence research**, submit a request to **Lyra (Intake Coordinator)** with:
- Specific market opportunity name
- Strategic context (why this matters to Crimson Leaf's incubation pipeline)
- Timeline

Lyra will determine whether to:
- **Extend an existing Tenant** (if one covers this domain)
- **Route to a deterministic tool** (if research is formulaic)
- **Propose a new Market Intelligence Tenant** (if the need is recurring and strategic)

### Option 2: Propose Market Intelligence as a Dedicated Tenant
If recurring market research is a core Genesis capability, you may request that Crimson Leaf **charter a dedicated Market Intelligence Tenant** with:
- A specialized CEO focused on competitive landscaping, TAM analysis, and industry trend analysis
- Clear boundaries (which markets, which question types)
- A distinct budget and charter

---

## Charter Guidance

Per **Section 3 (Forbidden Activities):**

> *"Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to drafting books, auditing spreadsheets, writing code, generating marketing copy, **conducting production research**, or preparing end-user reports."*

This analysis would constitute **production research** — a forbidden activity for Crimson Leaf's internal roster.

---

**Next Step:** Please clarify your request through Lyra, or propose a Market Intelligence Tenant charter for architectural review.