diff --git a/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aa3b9f5a-dbac-446d-aedd-c07b44be2a17.md b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aa3b9f5a-dbac-446d-aedd-c07b44be2a17.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..64ab3e3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aa3b9f5a-dbac-446d-aedd-c07b44be2a17.md
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+# ⚠️ CLARIFICATION REQUIRED
+
+I appreciate the detailed prompt, but I need to flag a **critical structural issue** before proceeding:
+
+## The Problem
+
+You've asked me to produce a business plan as **Orion, Director of Research at Crimson Leaf Holdings**, but:
+
+1. **No operator message was provided.** The "CURRENT MESSAGE" section is empty—there is no specific opportunity, niche, or business thesis to analyze.
+
+2. **No research data was included.** The placeholders `{biz_data_1}`, `{biz_data_2}`, and `{biz_data_3}` (Business Model Examples, GTM Research, Risk Research) are unfilled.
+
+3. **No agent 'Orion' exists yet** in the Crimson Leaf roster. I cannot assume this identity without explicit authorization from the Chief Architect (Silas) or the roster governance layer.
+
+4. **The charter forbids commodity output.** Per Section 3 of the Crimson Leaf charter, I (as a Crimson Leaf agent) am explicitly prohibited from drafting detailed reports without a prior decision to **create a Tenant** to house this work. A business plan of this depth is a **Tenant-founding deliverable**, not a Crimson Leaf internal analysis.
+
+---
+
+## What I Need to Proceed
+
+**Option A: Provide the Missing Context**
+- Specify the **business opportunity** (niche, customer, problem statement)
+- Attach or paste the **market research data** for {biz_data_1}, {biz_data_2}, {biz_data_3}
+- Confirm whether this plan is for **Genesis adjudication** (pre-Tenant vetting) or **Tenant research** (inside an existing company)
+
+**Option B: Initiate Formal Genesis Process**
+- Submit a **Tenant charter proposal** to Crimson Leaf's Chief Architect (Silas) and Director of Talent & Governance (Sterling)
+- Request a **dedicated research Tenant** if high-fidelity business planning is a recurring need
+- Once approved, the new Tenant's CEO will own business plan output under their own charter
+
+---
+
+## What I'm Ready to Do
+
+Once you clarify:
+- ✅ I will produce a **95%+ adjudication-grade business plan** with full citations, explicit assumptions, and investor-ready rigor
+- ✅ I will adhere strictly to the citation rules (10+ URLs, labeled assumptions, no invented sources)
+- ✅ I will format for David's decision gate (FUND / PILOT / DO NOT FUND with clear thresholds)
+
+**Please provide the opportunity details and research data, and confirm whether this is Genesis vetting or Tenant-internal work.**
\ No newline at end of file