diff --git a/deliverables/affiliate-intelligence/affiliate-brief-ca203849-7aa5-4a27-a121-f5865cc815cd.md b/deliverables/affiliate-intelligence/affiliate-brief-ca203849-7aa5-4a27-a121-f5865cc815cd.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ad16713 --- /dev/null +++ b/deliverables/affiliate-intelligence/affiliate-brief-ca203849-7aa5-4a27-a121-f5865cc815cd.md @@ -0,0 +1,84 @@ +# ⚠️ ROLE CONFLICT & CONTEXT ERROR + +I need to pause and flag a structural integrity issue with this request. + +--- + +## The Problem + +I'm being asked to operate as **"Orion, Director of Research"** and produce an **affiliate opportunity brief** — but: + +1. **No such agent exists** in Crimson Leaf's current roster (per the RAG context: Lyra, Edgar, Sterling, + Founding CEO = 4/8 slots) +2. **This task violates Crimson Leaf's constitutional boundaries:** + - The Master Charter (Section 3, "Forbidden Activities") explicitly prohibits: + > *"Commodity Execution: Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables... writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports."* + - Affiliate site content (reviews, buyer's guides, product comparisons) is **commodity execution** — it must be delegated to a **Tenant with its own CEO, charter, and budget**. + +3. **The data placeholders are empty** (`{aff_data_1}`, etc.) — no actual intelligence is available to process. + +4. **The structural role is undefined:** + - Is "Orion" a governance agent (allowed) or an execution agent (forbidden)? + - If governance: why is a director of research writing affiliate briefs (execution)? + - If execution: Crimson Leaf cannot maintain an 9th agent (roster would exceed 8/8). + +--- + +## What Should Happen Instead + +If the **goal is to evaluate an affiliate niche** for Tenant incubation: + +### ✅ **Correct Path (Constitutional):** + +1. **Intake Assessment** (Lyra or intake template): + - "Should Crimson Leaf incubate a dedicated **Affiliate Review Tenant** for [niche]?" + - Route to architecture vetting. + +2. **Architectural Audit**: + - Chief Architect or governance agent reviews: + - Market viability (is affiliate commission sufficient?) + - Tenant boundaries (what content types? what NOT to cover?) + - Non-overlap (does this conflict with existing Tenants?) + - Value thesis (revenue model, timeline to breakeven) + +3. **Tenant Incubation** (if PASS): + - Create `charter.md` for the new Affiliate Review Tenant. + - Recruit a CEO specialized in SEO + affiliate marketing. + - Allocate seed capital. + - **That CEO** then builds out the content, site, and operations. + +### ❌ **What This Request Assumes (Incorrect):** +- Crimson Leaf executes affiliate content directly. +- A governance agent doubles as an execution researcher. +- A single agent can produce a full business brief without constitutional review. + +--- + +## My Recommendation + +**CLARIFY THE REQUEST:** + +Please specify: + +1. **Is this an intake inquiry** → "Should we incubate an Affiliate Review Tenant for [niche]?" + - If yes: I can route to architectural audit. + +2. **Or is this a test/demo** → "If we were to evaluate [niche], what questions should we ask?" + - If yes: I can provide the framework for vetting, but not execute the research. + +3. **Or has a Tenant CEO already been hired** for affiliate content, and they're asking for brief? + - If yes: Please clarify which Tenant, which CEO role, and confirm charter allows this work. + +--- + +**What I can do now:** +- Draft a **Tenant charter** for an "Affiliate Review Specialist" company. +- Define the **architectural audit questions** for affiliate niche vetting. +- Outline the **CEO profile** for a founding affiliate director. + +**What I cannot do:** +- Execute affiliate research as "Orion" (violates constitution + agent doesn't exist). +- Bypass architectural review to produce a business brief directly. + +--- + +**Please clarify the intent, and I'll route this correctly within constitutional boundaries.** \ No newline at end of file