diff --git a/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-310f4307-f1ab-4e86-ae3a-ebb502211cfe.md b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-310f4307-f1ab-4e86-ae3a-ebb502211cfe.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..4dd4f22
--- /dev/null
+++ b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-310f4307-f1ab-4e86-ae3a-ebb502211cfe.md
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
+I appreciate the detailed setup, but I need to flag a critical issue before proceeding.
+
+---
+
+## BLOCKERS
+
+**1. No Operator Message / Opportunity Specification**
+
+The `*** CURRENT MESSAGE ***` section is empty:
+```
+Operator: 
+Message: 
+```
+
+I cannot produce a business plan without knowing **what opportunity you want me to analyze**. I need:
+- The specific business idea or market niche
+- The target customer segment
+- The core problem being solved
+- Any preliminary market signals or constraints
+
+**2. Missing Research Data**
+
+The template references three data placeholders that are empty:
+```
+{biz_data_1}  -- Business Model Examples
+{biz_data_2}  -- GTM Channel Research  
+{biz_data_3}  -- Risk and Failure Research
+```
+
+Without these sources, I cannot cite the 10+ required URLs or ground financial projections in real benchmarks.
+
+**3. Unclear Requester Authority**
+
+The task header says `*** CHAIR *** business_plan`, but per the RAG context, there is no agent named `business_plan` in Crimson Leaf's current roster (Lyra, Edgar, Sterling, + Founding CEO = 4/8 slots).
+
+This appears to be an **out-of-charter request** or a **role clarification issue**.
+
+---
+
+## RESOLUTION PATH
+
+Please provide:
+
+1. **The Opportunity Brief** (2-3 sentences):
+   - What business are we incubating?
+   - Who is the customer?
+   - Why now?
+
+2. **Research Data** or **Explicit Instruction**:
+   - If you have market research, GTM data, and risk analysis → paste it
+   - If you want me to make reasonable assumptions → state that explicitly (e.g., "Assume indie author web design market, $50-200M TAM, similar to Webflow/Squarespace GTM")
+
+3. **Authority Clarification**:
+   - Is this request coming from **Edgar** (CEO) or **Silas** (Chief Architect)?
+   - Should I produce this as a **Crimson Leaf governance document** or as a **Tenant charter + business thesis**?
+
+Once you clarify, I will produce a complete, investor-grade business plan with proper citations and financial rigor.
\ No newline at end of file