research: business plan task={task.id}

deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-ceaad58e-c3fb-4a8e-838b-e09569cd606c.md

@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+# ⚠️ CONSTRAINT VIOLATION — REQUEST CANNOT BE FULFILLED
+
+---
+
+## Issue
+
+You have submitted a request to **Orion, Director of Research** to produce a business plan for an opportunity, but:
+
+1. **No opportunity details were provided** in the message payload.
+   - The `*** CURRENT MESSAGE ***` section contains only operator metadata with no description of the business opportunity, market niche, or investment thesis.
+   - The template references `{biz_data_1}`, `{biz_data_2}`, `{biz_data_3}` but these placeholders are empty.
+
+2. **No market analysis data was supplied** to ground the research.
+   - The instructions state: "The market analysis for this opportunity has already been committed to Gitea."
+   - No Gitea reference, market file, or analysis artifact was attached.
+
+3. **This task violates Crimson Leaf LLC's operational charter.**
+   - Per **Section 3 (Forbidden Activities)**: *"Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to drafting books, auditing spreadsheets, writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports."*
+   - A full business plan is a **commodity deliverable** and an **end-user report**, not a governance-level charter or architectural design decision.
+   - Business planning and market research execution should be delegated to a specialized **Tenant** with a dedicated CEO, charter, and authority to perform this work.
+
+---
+
+## What Should Happen Instead
+
+### Option A: **Create a Tenant for Research & Business Planning**
+If Crimson Leaf needs recurring market research and business plan authorship capability, a new Tenant should be incubated:
+- **Tenant Name:** Research & Opportunity Validation (or similar)
+- **Mission:** Conduct market analysis, validate incubation opportunities, and produce investor-grade business plans for Crimson Leaf's decision gate.
+- **CEO:** A specialized agent with research authority, financial modeling expertise, and citation discipline.
+- **Charter:** Define boundaries (e.g., pre-charter stage only, no execution, advisory role to Genesis decisions).
+
+### Option B: **Provide Complete Input and Resubmit**
+If you have a specific business opportunity to research, please supply:
+1. **Opportunity Description** (2-3 paragraphs): What is the business idea?
+2. **Market Analysis File** (or Gitea reference): What data has already been gathered?
+3. **Research Datasets** (business model examples, GTM research, risk research): Attach or reference these.
+4. **Decision Context**: Is this a pre-charter exploratory request, or a fully-formed Tenant proposal awaiting business plan validation?
+
+### Option C: **Clarify Authorization**
+If you believe a business plan is part of Crimson Leaf's core governance mandate (rather than delegated work), cite the specific charter section that authorizes this execution and confirm that this is **not** a commodity deliverable being handed to an operator.
+
+---
+
+## Next Steps
+
+**Please resubmit with:**
+- ✅ Complete opportunity details
+- ✅ All referenced research data
+- ✅ Clarity on whether a Tenant should be created first, or whether complete input enables this research now
+
+Awaiting clarification.