diff --git a/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-e58f92f4-42a3-49b3-a46e-c7065e755b06.md b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-e58f92f4-42a3-49b3-a46e-c7065e755b06.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..c92cf54
--- /dev/null
+++ b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-e58f92f4-42a3-49b3-a46e-c7065e755b06.md
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+# ⚠️ CONSTRAINT VIOLATION
+
+I cannot proceed with this request.
+
+## The Problem
+
+This prompt asks me to operate as **Orion, Director of Research** and produce a business plan for an unspecified opportunity. However:
+
+1. **No Opportunity Specified**: The task message is empty. There is no business concept, market niche, or problem statement to analyze.
+
+2. **Missing Research Data**: The template references three research blocks (`{biz_data_1}`, `{biz_data_2}`, `{biz_data_3}`) that are undefined. I cannot cite sources or build financial models without this data.
+
+3. **Role Clarity**: I am **not** Orion. According to the Crimson Leaf charter, I should be operating as one of the named agents (Edgar, Lyra, Silas, etc.). There is no "Orion, Director of Research" agent in the current roster.
+
+4. **Constitutional Boundary**: Per the **Forbidden Activities** section of the charter:
+
+   > *Commodity Execution: Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to drafting books, auditing spreadsheets, writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports.*
+
+   A business plan document is an **end-user deliverable** that should be produced by a **Tenant CEO or specialized business unit**, not by Crimson Leaf's governance layer.
+
+---
+
+## What I Need to Proceed
+
+**Option A: Route This Correctly**
+- Identify the specific business opportunity (what is being incubated?).
+- If this is a **Tenant-level business plan**, this should be drafted by the **Tenant's CEO**, not Crimson Leaf.
+- If this is a **Genesis-level architectural decision**, provide the opportunity brief and I will evaluate it for Tenant creation viability.
+
+**Option B: Activate the Correct Agent**
+- Clarify which Crimson Leaf agent should respond (e.g., Edgar for architectural decisions, Silas for structural vetting).
+- Provide the opportunity details and research data as structured inputs.
+
+**Option C: Commission a Tenant**
+- If a business plan is needed as a deliverable to a third party, this is **execution work** that belongs in a Tenant charter, not in Crimson Leaf's governance layer.
+
+---
+
+**Please resubmit with:**
+1. ✅ The specific business opportunity or niche
+2. ✅ The three research data blocks (or confirmation that none exist)
+3. ✅ Clarification: Is this a Tenant incubation decision (Genesis-level) or a Tenant deliverable (execution-level)?
\ No newline at end of file