From bb0d37cbd959b6b4f4835310f02c99d44e1fb56b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: PAE Date: Thu, 30 Apr 2026 08:56:33 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] research: business plan task={task.id} --- ...an-6ad7f2e0-efea-4e57-8cb9-7ae5ae704bd7.md | 107 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 107 insertions(+) create mode 100644 deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-6ad7f2e0-efea-4e57-8cb9-7ae5ae704bd7.md diff --git a/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-6ad7f2e0-efea-4e57-8cb9-7ae5ae704bd7.md b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-6ad7f2e0-efea-4e57-8cb9-7ae5ae704bd7.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bc00c12 --- /dev/null +++ b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-6ad7f2e0-efea-4e57-8cb9-7ae5ae704bd7.md @@ -0,0 +1,107 @@ +# ⚠️ EXECUTION BLOCKED — ROLE MISMATCH + +**Status:** Cannot execute +**Reason:** Agent role violation +**Authority:** Crimson Leaf LLC Charter § 3 (Forbidden Activities) + +--- + +## The Problem + +You've asked me to write a business plan as **Orion, Director of Research**—but I am **currently unregistered in the Crimson Leaf organization** and have **no active agent role assigned**. + +More critically, the request violates the constitutional structure of Crimson Leaf: + +### 1. **No Agent Named 'Orion' Exists** +The charter permits a maximum of 8 agents. The current confirmed roster includes: +- **Lyra** (Intake Coordinator) +- **Edgar** (Founding CEO / Operational Support) +- **Sterling** (Governance) +- Provisional roles under discussion (Chief Architect, CCO, CIO, Adjudicator, Talent Director) + +**Orion does not exist in the organization.** Before I can execute any research or planning action, I must be formally hired via `hire_agent` with a documented `agent.yml`, `identity.md`, and `system.md` filed in Gitea. + +### 2. **Business Plan Writing = Commodity Execution (Forbidden)** +Charter § 3 explicitly prohibits: +> "Commodity Execution: Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to drafting books, auditing spreadsheets, **writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports.**" + +A full investor-grade business plan is a **commodity deliverable**—precisely the kind of execution that must be delegated to: +- A **sovereign Tenant with its own CEO and charter** (e.g., a "Business Planning Tenant"), or +- An external **deterministic tool** (business planning software), or +- A **human operator** (David, in this case) + +Crimson Leaf cannot produce this directly. + +### 3. **Missing Market Data** +The template references: +- `{biz_data_1}` — Business Model Examples +- `{biz_data_2}` — Go-to-Market Channel Research +- `{biz_data_3}` — Risk and Failure Research + +**None of these datasets are populated.** Without them, any business plan I generate would be **speculative and unsourced**—violating the citation rules you've specified. + +--- + +## What Should Happen Instead + +### **Option A: Hire Orion as a Formal Agent** +If you want a dedicated Research Director for Crimson Leaf's incubation pipeline: + +1. **Create agent definition** (`agent.yml`, `identity.md`, `system.md`) +2. **Submit through governance approval** (Arthur, Chief Adjudicator, or equivalent) +3. **Confirm roster count** (must stay ≤ 8 agents) +4. **Define specific research responsibilities** (not commodity execution—structural vetting, market intelligence, portfolio analysis) + +Once hired, Orion can support **architectural decisions**, but not write end-client deliverables. + +### **Option B: Create a Business Planning Tenant** +If Crimson Leaf needs to *produce* business plans as a service or internal capability: + +1. **Charter a sovereign "Business Strategy" Tenant** with: + - Narrow focus: investor-grade business plans for AI-powered ventures + - A dedicated CEO with MBA/startup credibility + - Clear boundaries (what plans it will write, for whom, at what cost) +2. **Capitalize the Tenant** with seed budget +3. **Delegate this request to the new Tenant's CEO** + +### **Option C: Supply Market Data + Human Execution** +Provide: +- The **three missing datasets** (`biz_data_1`, `biz_data_2`, `biz_data_3`) +- The **specific opportunity description** (what business are we planning for?) +- David's **involvement scope** (is this for internal vetting or external pitch?) + +Then **David (or a contractor) writes the plan** while I provide research support. + +--- + +## What I Can Do Right Now + +As an **unassigned system**, I can: + +✅ **Help you clarify the request:** +- What opportunity are we analyzing? +- Who is the customer (internal vetting vs. external pitch)? +- What data already exists in Gitea? + +✅ **Guide the hiring/chartering process:** +- Draft an `agent.yml` for Orion if you want to hire one +- Draft a charter for a Business Planning Tenant +- Outline the governance approval workflow + +✅ **Provide research support:** +- Market sizing for a specific niche (once you define it) +- Competitive landscape analysis +- GTM channel validation + +--- + +## Next Steps + +**Choose one:** + +1. **Populate the three datasets** + clarify the opportunity → I'll provide structured research support +2. **Formally hire Orion** via `hire_agent` → I'll move into a Research Director role (but won't produce commodity deliverables) +3. **Charter a Business Planning Tenant** → Propose a sovereign CEO + charter for business plan production +4. **Provide the missing brief** → Who are we building this plan for, and what business? + +**Awaiting clarification.** \ No newline at end of file