diff --git a/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aad6ff0e-77a7-4c9b-b8fc-8ae8901b6497.md b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aad6ff0e-77a7-4c9b-b8fc-8ae8901b6497.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..7f78898
--- /dev/null
+++ b/deliverables/business-plans/business-plan-aad6ff0e-77a7-4c9b-b8fc-8ae8901b6497.md
@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
+# CHAIR MESSAGE RECEIVED
+
+I appreciate the detailed context, but I need to flag a critical constraint before proceeding.
+
+---
+
+## Issue: No Opportunity Provided
+
+Your message structure indicates I should produce a business plan for a specific opportunity, but **the operator message is empty**:
+
+```
+*** CURRENT MESSAGE ***
+Operator: 
+Message: 
+```
+
+The template you've provided is comprehensive and well-structured, but it requires:
+
+1. **A specific business opportunity** (problem, market niche, proposed solution)
+2. **Market research data** (referenced as `{biz_data_1}`, `{biz_data_2}`, `{biz_data_3}` but not populated)
+3. **Clear scope** (what Tenant should this plan incubate, or is this a portfolio-level assessment?)
+
+---
+
+## What I Need to Proceed
+
+Please provide:
+
+### A. **Opportunity Brief** (1-2 sentences)
+Example: *"Launch an AI-powered service to generate SEO-optimized blog content for indie e-commerce founders, priced at $299/month for 4 articles."*
+
+### B. **Market Research Data** (or pointers to it)
+- TAM / market size
+- Growth rate / demand signals
+- Competitor landscape
+- Customer pain points
+
+### C. **Scope Clarification**
+- Is this a **new Tenant incubation** (via the Genesis Protocol)?
+- Or a **portfolio-level opportunity assessment** (should this exist as a Tenant at all)?
+- Who is the intended CEO/founding leader?
+
+---
+
+## My Role (Orion, Director of Research)
+
+Once you provide the opportunity, I will produce:
+
+✅ **Investor-grade business plan** (following your template exactly)  
+✅ **All financial figures with stated assumptions**  
+✅ **10+ cited sources** (no invented URLs)  
+✅ **Honest uncertainty flagging**  
+✅ **Constitutional alignment check** vs. Crimson Leaf charter  
+
+**Please resubmit with the opportunity details, and I'll deliver the full plan.**
\ No newline at end of file