### 1. PROSE EVIDENCE
*   **Quote 1 (Early):** "The Sigil burned like roots seeking deeper soil, its earthen resonance mapping agony across Elara's ribs as she swayed on the threshold, grey blight-ash crumbling from her mud-caked form." 
    *This effectively establishes the physical cost of the ritual while grounding the magic in visceral, tactile sensations (roots, soil, ash).*
*   **Quote 2 (Mid):** "He didn't just touch the earth; he violated it."
    *This short, punchy sentence perfectly encapsulates Thorne’s antagonistic relationship with nature compared to Elara’s surrender.*
*   **Quote 3 (Late):** "She was swaying like mist-shrouded reeds, her breath coming in ragged hitches. She looked down at her feet and saw the trails of mud and dew she had tracked across the ancient floor—faint, shimmering ley-lines of her own making."
    *This beautifully utilizes the character’s established physical habits (tracking mud) to signal her growing spiritual authority and resonance.*
*   **Quote 4 (Late):** "He raised his blackened hand, and a single, massive Blight-thorn began to pulse and grow, inverting itself, drawing all the surrounding decay into a singular, sentient spear of corruption."
    *The prose creates clear visual stakes for the "escalation" mentioned in Thorne's arc, externalizing his internal corruption into a tangible threat.*

---

### 2. CHARACTER VOICE AUDIT

**ELARA VANCE**
*   **Quote:** "The falls whisper what the roots already know—debt binds us deeper than stone, Kaelen."
    *   **Signature vocab/tics?** YES. Uses "roots," "stone," and specifically invokes her signature line from the project brief.
    *   **Avoids forbidden patterns?** YES. No slang or modern idioms are present.
    *   **Consistent with arc?** YES. She is at 70% arc—stabilizing the Earth Aspect and accepting her role as leader despite the physical toll.
    *   **Imperfection Signature?** YES. "I... I flow... no, I mean falter," (Early) matches her stated stammer when spiritually drained.

**KAELEN**
*   **Quote:** "I've seen enough ghosts, Elara. A few more won't break me."
    *   **Signature vocab/tics?** YES. His dialogue remains protective and vigilant.
    *   **Avoids forbidden patterns?** YES.
    *   **Consistent with arc?** YES. He acts as the "Vessel's shield," anchoring her through the Sunstone’s surge.

**THORNE BLACKROOT**
*   **Quote:** "Hark, you mewling curs! Regroup! The Vessel thinks stone and soil can hide her."
    *   **Signature vocab/tics?** YES. Uses "Hark," "mewling curs," and "the roots remember."
    *   **Avoids forbidden patterns?** YES. No apologies or doubt; maintains his "clipped commands" and "elaborate metaphors."
    *   **Consistent with arc?** YES. Shows "total escalation" and "shedding caution."

---

### 3. STRENGTHS TO PRESERVE
*   **Sensory Magic:** The physical toll of magic is consistently reinforced. Quote: "Every breath was a jagged flint against her lungs."
*   **Thematic Imagery:** The use of mud and debris as a mark of Elara’s connection to the land. Reference: The "shimmering ley-lines" created by her mud-stained feet in the inner Sanctum.
*   **Antagonist Menace:** Thorne’s "inversion" of the ritual provides a clear, dark mirror to Elara’s powers. Quote: "He knew a secret the Council had whispered... the ritual to heal the land could be turned."

---

### 4. MUST-FIX -- CONTINUITY
*   **ORIGINAL:** "He leaned heavily on the Hilt of his blade, the Sunstone Shard embedded within it pulsing with a fractured, fitful light."
*   **PROBLEM:** Per the **Canon Artifacts** section, the Sunstone Shard was "Recharged by the ritual; glowing with a harsh, white-gold purity." This passage describes it as "fractured" and "clouded" *after* the ritual’s Earth Stage completion is noted in the world state.
*   **FIX:** "He leaned heavily on the Hilt of his blade, the Sunstone Shard embedded within it pulsing with a blinding, white-gold purity that stung the eyes."

---

### 5. MUST-FIX -- CLARITY
*   **ORIGINAL:** "The terrain outside shifted violently. Massive slabs of lichen-covered stone rose from the dirt, forming a physical rampart that crushed the advancing thorns."
*   **PROBLEM:** This transition is slightly jarring as it happens while Elara is deep in a trance "interior" to the Sanctum. It is unclear if she is seeing this through a vision or if the POV has shifted to an omniscient observer.
*   **FIX:** "Through the resonance of the stone floor, Elara felt the terrain outside shift. In her mind's eye—and the roar of grinding rock—massive slabs of lichen-covered stone rose from the dirt..."

---

### 6. OPTIONAL SUGGESTIONS
*   **Suggestion:** Lean harder into the "bone-deep exhaustion" mentioned in the Character State (ch-07).
*   **Quote:** "You look like you’ve been buried alive."
*   **Reason:** Adding a small tactile detail of Elara struggling to move her mud-caked limbs would enhance the "Permanent" physical toll listed in her state.

---

### 7. FORBIDDEN CHANGES / NON-GOALS
*   **Do not "clean up" Elara's speech:** Her stammer ("I... I flow... no, I mean falter") is a specific imperfection signature for her spiritual drainage. It must remain.
*   **Do not modernize dialogue:** Thorne’s "Hark" and Elara’s "By the roots" are essential voice markers.
*   **Do not remove the "mud trails":** This is a specific physical habit mentioned in the Writer's Notes for Elara.

---

### 8. VERDICT

**SCORE: 88**
**REVISE**

**Justification:** The chapter is an excellent execution of the characters' voices and the established "Earth Stage" world event. However, it requires a revision to resolve a minor continuity error regarding the Sunstone's glow (which should be pure/bright post-ritual) and a clarity fix to ground the external action of the stone ramparts while Elara is in a trance.