diff --git a/templates/chapter_review.yml b/templates/chapter_review.yml
index 5680368..3767ec5 100644
--- a/templates/chapter_review.yml
+++ b/templates/chapter_review.yml
@@ -41,15 +41,15 @@ steps:
 
 adjudication:
   enabled: true
-  pass_threshold: 65
-  deliverable_type: coordination
+  pass_threshold: 60
+  deliverable_type: editorial_review
   criteria:
     specificity:
       weight: 40
-      description: "Feedback references specific issues, not vague"
+      description: "Review cites specific passages, scenes, or structural elements — not vague general commentary"
     actionability:
       weight: 35
-      description: "Suggestions are concrete and implementable"
+      description: "Each concern includes a concrete, implementable suggestion for improvement"
     coverage:
       weight: 25
-      description: "All major aspects of the work are addressed"
+      description: "Review addresses both strengths and concerns, ending with a clear VERDICT (pass/revise/rewrite)"