enforce word count in chapter_polish and book_chapter templates

- chapter_polish: add explicit 'chapter_target_words minimum' warning to think hint
  with instruction to EXPAND scenes to reach target length
- chapter_polish: add word_count criterion (30%) to adjudication, restructure weights
- book_chapter PASS 1: strengthen word count instruction with explicit stop-early warning
- book_chapter: add word_count criterion (30%) to adjudication, restructure weights

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
This commit is contained in:
David Baity
2026-03-12 11:38:07 -04:00
parent 18b4689947
commit 1e2cb6e875
2 changed files with 27 additions and 9 deletions

View File

@@ -95,7 +95,10 @@ steps:
- Every scene beat moves the story forward OR reveals character (no filler)
- End with the CLOSING HOOK you planned
- Match the prose style guide: {prose_style}
- Target length: {chapter_target_words} words — write the full chapter, not a summary
- Target length: {chapter_target_words} words — write the FULL chapter, not a summary
- ⚠️ DO NOT stop early. If you have not reached {chapter_target_words} words, continue
writing — add interiority, sensory detail, extended dialogue beats, and scene transitions
until you hit the target. Short chapters will be REJECTED in adjudication.
Output ONLY the polished chapter text.
Start directly with the chapter title (e.g., "Chapter N: [Title]") and opening line.
@@ -176,15 +179,18 @@ adjudication:
pass_threshold: 80
deliverable_type: consumer
criteria:
narrative_flow:
word_count:
weight: 30
description: "Chapter meets the {chapter_target_words}-word minimum; under-length chapters fail"
narrative_flow:
weight: 25
description: "Story progresses naturally with good pacing"
character_voice:
weight: 25
weight: 20
description: "Characters are distinct and consistent"
prose_quality:
weight: 25
weight: 15
description: "Writing is polished and engaging"
continuity:
weight: 20
weight: 10
description: "Consistent with prior chapters and canon"

View File

@@ -29,6 +29,14 @@ steps:
Genre: {genre_name} | Audience: {genre_audience}
Chapter: {task.message}
TARGET LENGTH: {chapter_target_words} words minimum.
⚠️ CRITICAL — LENGTH REQUIREMENT:
- The polished chapter MUST be at least {chapter_target_words} words.
- DO NOT shorten the chapter. Expand scenes, deepen emotional beats, and add sensory
detail as needed to reach the word count target.
- If the original chapter is under target, the polish is your opportunity to bring it up.
- Under-length chapters will be REJECTED by the editorial board regardless of prose quality.
You have received a full editorial review from three editors.
EDITORIAL CONSENSUS:
@@ -48,6 +56,7 @@ steps:
Preserve everything the editors marked as STRENGTHS.
Do not add new plot elements not already present.
Match the genre tone and audience level throughout.
Expand scenes with sensory detail, interiority, and dialogue to reach {chapter_target_words} words.
Output ONLY the fully rewritten chapter text.
- type: document
@@ -61,15 +70,18 @@ adjudication:
pass_threshold: 90
deliverable_type: consumer
criteria:
word_count:
weight: 30
description: "Chapter meets the {chapter_target_words}-word minimum; longer is better, shorter fails"
prose_quality:
weight: 35
weight: 25
description: "Language is refined, no awkward phrasing"
consistency:
weight: 25
weight: 20
description: "Style and tone uniform throughout"
engagement:
weight: 25
weight: 20
description: "Text is compelling and polished"
formatting:
weight: 15
weight: 5
description: "Proper formatting, no artifacts"