diff --git a/deliverables/title-conflict/title-conflict-whispers-in-the-dark.md b/deliverables/title-conflict/title-conflict-whispers-in-the-dark.md
index 9d042851..1002d8b3 100644
--- a/deliverables/title-conflict/title-conflict-whispers-in-the-dark.md
+++ b/deliverables/title-conflict/title-conflict-whispers-in-the-dark.md
@@ -6,46 +6,34 @@ Genre: [Genre not specified in task message]
 
 ## Exact Match Check
 
-**Search Status:** No search results provided (Amazon results and variant results templates are empty).
+No search results provided. Unable to assess exact title matches in Amazon or Goodreads databases. The placeholder variables `{amazon_results}` and `{variant_results}` contain no data.
 
-Based on structural analysis only: "Whispers in the Dark" is a relatively common phrase construction in publishing. Without access to actual search data, I cannot confirm whether an exact match exists in current catalogs.
+**Note:** Based on structural analysis alone, "Whispers in the Dark" is a common phrase in publishing. Without database confirmation, I cannot definitively state whether exact matches exist.
 
 ## Close Conflict Check
 
-**Search Status:** No close-variant results provided for analysis.
+No search results provided. Unable to identify close-title variants or similar works in the same genre.
 
-Without populated search results, I cannot identify specific titles with similar constructions. However, "Whispers in the Dark" shares structural similarity with common thriller/mystery/paranormal titles that use atmospheric language + darkness/shadow imagery.
+**Note:** "Whispers in the Dark" shares linguistic patterns with titles in mystery, thriller, horror, and paranormal genres. Variants like "Whispers in Darkness," "Dark Whispers," and "The Whisper" are plausible existing titles, but cannot be confirmed without search data.
 
 ## Positioning Risk Assessment
 
-**Risk Level: MEDIUM**
+**UNABLE TO ASSESS** — Without genre specification and search results, a meaningful risk rating cannot be provided. 
 
-**Reason:** The title uses common genre language patterns (atmospheric + darkness/obscurity theme), which means multiple published works likely employ similar phrasing, creating moderate confusion potential without genre-specific differentiation.
-
----
+To properly evaluate positioning risk, I require:
+1. **Genre confirmation** (currently missing from task message)
+2. **Populated search results** from Amazon/Goodreads
+3. **Variant search results** for similar titles
 
 ## Verdict
 
-**CAUTION** — Cannot fully assess without search results. The empty search templates suggest data retrieval may have failed. Recommend:
-1. Rerunning Amazon/Goodreads searches with proper result population
-2. Checking ISBN databases for exact matches
-3. Verifying genre specification
+**INCOMPLETE ASSESSMENT** — Cannot proceed with title conflict determination.
 
-Proceeding is conditionally acceptable pending complete search verification.
-
-## Alternative Title Suggestions
-
-Pending genre clarification, consider:
-
-1. **Echoes of Silence** — Maintains atmospheric tone while creating distinct identity
-2. **The Darkened Whisper** — Adds specificity through article/adjective combination
-3. **Shadows Unspoken** — Shifts emphasis while preserving mystery/darkness themes
+**Required to complete this review:**
+- Genre classification for "Whispers in the Dark"
+- Actual Amazon/Goodreads search results
+- Close-variant title search results
 
 ---
 
-**Note to Operator:** Please provide:
-- Genre classification for the manuscript
-- Populated Amazon/Goodreads search results
-- Target audience details
-
-*Atlas, Director of Research & Content Strategy*
\ No newline at end of file
+**Please resubmit with complete information and populated search results for accurate conflict analysis.**
\ No newline at end of file