diff --git a/templates/chapter_roundtable.yml b/templates/chapter_roundtable.yml index 3fd3406..75df20b 100644 --- a/templates/chapter_roundtable.yml +++ b/templates/chapter_roundtable.yml @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ name: chapter_roundtable description: > - Editorial roundtable — available editors debate the chapter in 2–3 structured rounds. + Editorial roundtable -- available editors debate the chapter in 2-3 structured rounds. Each round, each participant responds to the others' most recent positions. The output is a categorized consensus (MUST APPLY / OPTIONAL / PRESERVE) for the bounded editorial polish step. @@ -65,18 +65,18 @@ steps: Before calling CONSENSUS REACHED, ensure the group has resolved any disagreements. If two editors disagree on whether a change is required (one says MUST, one says optional), the MUST position prevails unless the other editor can argue it would damage the chapter. - The polish step cannot reconcile unresolved debate — resolve it here. + The polish step cannot reconcile unresolved debate -- resolve it here. When the group has reached sufficient consensus for the polish step, - end your response with this EXACT block — no variations, no paraphrasing: + end your response with this EXACT block -- no variations, no paraphrasing: CONSENSUS REACHED CRITIQUE: [One concise paragraph summarizing the full editorial consensus] MUST APPLY: - - [Must-fix item 1 — continuity error, clarity issue, or structural problem only] - - [Must-fix item 2 — if applicable] + - [Must-fix item 1 -- continuity error, clarity issue, or structural problem only] + - [Must-fix item 2 -- if applicable] OPTIONAL (only if explicitly agreed by majority as low-risk): - - [Optional craft suggestion — clearly labeled, not required] + - [Optional craft suggestion -- clearly labeled, not required] PRESERVE: - [Strength or intentional voice choice that must NOT be changed] - [Additional preserve item if applicable] @@ -85,7 +85,7 @@ steps: VERDICT rules: - PASS: no MUST APPLY items remain after the debate - REVISE: one or more MUST APPLY items require correction - - Do NOT use REWRITE as a verdict — the polish step is surgical, not a rebuild. + - Do NOT use REWRITE as a verdict -- the polish step is surgical, not a rebuild. If the chapter is so broken that only a full rewrite would fix it, flag that in CRITIQUE and set VERDICT to REVISE so the polish step addresses what it can. @@ -103,7 +103,7 @@ steps: - chapter_verdict: PASS or REVISE (never REWRITE) - key_changes: the complete MUST APPLY section as a single string, including any OPTIONAL items that were agreed upon and any PRESERVE notes, clearly labeled. - This field is the full contract for chapter_polish — include all sections. + This field is the full contract for chapter_polish -- include all sections. spawn: - task_type: chapter_polish task_name: "Polish: {chapter_ref}"