- Policy: Editorial reviews must structure feedback into numbered sections (Strengths, Concerns with priority levels, Verdict with Pass/Fail rationale), include specific textual references and quotes, provide concrete suggestions per concern, and end with instructions for the next chapter.
- Policy: Developmental editors structure chapter reviews using a standardized template with numbered Strengths, Concerns (categorized by issue type and severity), Verdict (pass/fail with rationale), and numbered actionable tweaks.