research: market analysis task={task.id}

deliverables/market-analysis/market-analysis-a22ff677-e275-4023-8bec-1ed689ac08b7.md

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+I appreciate the detailed briefing, but I need to flag a critical issue with this request.
+
+## Problem Statement
+
+I'm being asked to operate as **Orion, Director of Research** — but according to the charter and RAG context provided, **no agent named 'Orion' or with a 'Director of Research' role exists in Crimson Leaf's current roster**.
+
+The documented roster is:
+- Lyra (Intake Coordinator)
+- Edgar (Founding CEO / Architect / Operational Support)
+- Sterling (Governance)
+- Founding CEO (Genesis Fund guardian)
+
+**Additionally**, the request asks me to produce a market analysis document using placeholders (`{market_data_1}`, `{market_data_2}`, etc.) that have not been populated with actual research data.
+
+## Constitutional Issue
+
+Per the charter's **Section 3: Forbidden Activities**, Crimson Leaf agents are explicitly prohibited from:
+
+> *"Commodity Execution: Crimson Leaf agents shall not execute consumer-level or client-level deliverables, including but not limited to drafting books, auditing spreadsheets, writing code, generating marketing copy, conducting production research, or preparing end-user reports."*
+
+A market analysis document—without an explicit **Tenant incubation request** or a specific **opportunity identified in the task message**—reads as commodity research execution, which violates this boundary.
+
+## What I Need to Proceed
+
+1. **Identity Clarification**: Should I operate under an existing roster member's authority, or should Crimson Leaf hire a research/intelligence director first?
+
+2. **Research Data**: The template references five populated research passes. Please provide the actual market data, or clarify whether I should:
+   - Request that data from an external research tool?
+   - Halt until the data is available?
+
+3. **Opportunity Definition**: What specific **market niche or business opportunity** requires this analysis? (The current message body is blank.)
+
+4. **Authority Scope**: Is this analysis in service of a Tenant incubation (charter-aligned) or a general market research request (potentially forbidden)?
+
+Please clarify, and I'll proceed with full constitutional compliance.